• Parish news

Tonal Splendor: Details on the Organ Restoration Project

May 24, 2018

Not a day passes that I don’t dream about your magnificent instruments I played over there; their marvelous touch, their fine tone, their perfect and sensitive action haunt me. It seems as though I were dreaming when I think of Trinity Church, Boston, of St John’s, Los Angeles, Hollywood High School, Williamstown and Utica.

-Louis Vierne (1870-1937), organist of Notre Dame Cathedral, Paris

writing to Ernest Skinner after a 1927 United States tour

Trinity’s pipe organ is critical to leading worship, although like so much else that occurs during church, we don’t often stop to think about it. However, in a typical service, the organ sounds an astonishing 30 and 40 percent of the time, accompanying hymns, choir, psalms and all the other service music. When an instrument is so central to a church’s goals, it should be an inspiration to hear and play  — as distinctive as Trinity Church itself. The current organ project has two central goals: flexibility and tone.

Flexibility: A New Console

In 1926, when the nave Skinner organ was installed, both organs were governed by a tall console on the north side of the chancel. Its cloistering height complicated the player’s ability to conduct the choir, and its primitive combination memory made governing what was then Boston’s largest organ a tall order.

In 1956, a new console was provided, now on the south side of the chancel. From this vantage, players could hear the chancel organ and choir in better balance, and the console’s low profile permitted easier conducting from the console. In some ways, this new console was a marvel of its time, as miniaturized as the old console had been large, and provided with numerous features.  In some instances, the reduction measures were drastic, even to the point of reducing the keyboards from four to three. In several instances, multiple stops were controlled by a single knob; certain stops were unavailable on their own.

In time, these space-saving measures have proven limiting. The new console now under construction is only marginally larger than the present one, but will once again contain four keyboards and individual knobs for every stop. The latest technology will include a sophisticated combination memory system, user-definable options via iPad, and a record-playback function. This last feature is most useful, as it allows organists (particularly visiting artists) to hear their own playing from the nave, as the congregation will, and thus judge balances, adjust tempi, and refine the choice of stops. Like the present console, the new one will be on a mobile dolly, so that it may be moved to the center of the chancel for visibility during solo concerts.

The new console is being built by Richard Houghten of Milan, Michigan, and J. Zamberlan & Co., in Wintersville, Ohio. Mr. Houghten has worked at Trinity before, in the 1980s converting the organ’s original electro-pneumatic controls to its first solid-state system. In Boston alone, he has worked on the consoles at St Paul’s Cathedral; The First Church of Christ, Scientist, Extension (Mother Church); Harvard University; Park Street UCC in Arlington. Mr. Zamberlan has helped Mr. Houghten construct new consoles for Duke University Chapel, Christ Church Cathedral in Houston, and River Road Church (Baptist) in Richmond. Richard Webster, Colin Lynch, and Trinity’s curator of organs Jonathan Ambrosino, have all taken an active part in designing the new console which will be installed during August.

Tonal Splendor: Recapturing the Skinner Sound

One of the glories of Trinity Church is that Richardson’s resplendent interior has never been lost to subsequent modification, thus keeping at bay the tide of modernism and its “less-is-more” philosophy. Not so with the organ, which after 1926 was revised to keep in tune with the musicological times. In tonal terms, this meant an ever-leaner sound thought to be clearer for the music of Bach, and more transparent for choral leadership. Along the way, however, the grand richness of the original 1926 Skinner ensemble was lost, although Skinner’s characteristic orchestral colors (French Horn, English Horn, Celesta, vibrant strings) were retained. (Mechanically, the Trinity organs have always been maintained in excellent condition.)

The current project seeks to recast the nave organ along its original 1926 lines. Since 2012, the Church has slowly acquired a stockpile of Skinner and Aeolian-Skinner pipes from the general period of Trinity’s organ (1923-1934). Now with sufficient pipes, the process is beginning.

This work is a collaboration of Trinity’s former and current organ curators: Foley-Baker Inc., of Tolland, Connecticut (who renovated the nave organ in 1999-2001, and the chancel organ in 2007), and Jonathan Ambrosino, who also maintains the organs at Old South Church and Church of the Advent. Foley-Baker is handling the larger pipes, installing not only a vintage 16ft Open Wood stop but also re-activating the southern green-painted façade pipe, which date from 1877 yet have not been heard since 1926. Mr. Ambrosino is handling the remainder, reconditioning the vintage pipes Trinity has purchased, fitting them to the mechanisms, and installing them at Trinity. At the conclusion of the project (November 2019), he will regulate and re-tune all the pipes. A key additional firm is Broome & Co. LLC, specialists in the reconditioning of reed pipes.

Many people will be curious to know what the organ will sound like once recast, or whether they will be able to tell the difference. The resounding answer is YES. The goal here is not a louder organ, but something more supportive of the human voice. In the increase of brilliance and brashness over the years, the Trinity organ has become less encouraging in its support of singing; when the organ starts blaring, the people stop singing. A warm, rich, supporting sound, one that is strong, ceremonial yet not overpowering, will help lift the congregations and choirs of Trinity Church to their greatest heights yet.

-Jonathan Ambrosino & Colin Lynch

View or download specifications for the updated organ.